This is my attempt to repair the RROD Xbox 360 from the earlier assessment. It did not work. I hope you, and me, can learn from my mistakes and see if you can repair yours with more success!
I thought I’d try something a little different for this video, so we’ve got high-speed footage of the repair with a voiceover recorded afterwards. Unfortunately, speeding everything up eight times doesn’t make the job any less tedious. Every minute of footage represents about eight minutes of me struggling with this thing!
The first challenge was getting the grey plastic clips off the case. I spent a ridiculous amount of time trying to work out how to release them, and just when I thought I was getting somewhere, another part of the housing decided to hold everything together. Eventually the plastic covers came off and I could start working my way into the metal chassis.
There were plenty more screws to remove, along with the shielding, DVD drive and cooling fans. Naturally, just when I thought the motherboard was ready to come out, I discovered another screw hiding beneath the front section. I do love consoles that make you work for it!
Next came the X-clamps holding the heatsinks onto the processors. I’d been looking at some of the Xbox 360 repair methods floating around the internet, and decided to have a go at replacing the original clamps with screws and washers. There was also the idea of heating the board with a heat gun. In hindsight, perhaps combining several experimental repair methods wasn’t my finest moment.
Getting the clamps off was another adventure. I tried working around them with a small tool and came uncomfortably close to damaging the motherboard traces. A more suitable plastic tool would have been a better choice, but by this stage I was already committed to making everything unnecessarily difficult.
The old thermal compound wasn’t particularly cooperative either. It was so stubborn that I wondered whether somebody had mixed concrete into it. Eventually I got the heatsinks off, although cleaning the remaining material proved rather harder than expected.
Then came the heat gun. Have a look at the footage as the heat goes onto the motherboard. You can actually see the board flexing, and then moving again as it cools! That’s not exactly what I wanted to see. I may have applied heat for too long, and the board wasn’t supported particularly well during the attempt.
It was a fairly spectacular demonstration of why uncontrolled heating can make an already faulty motherboard considerably worse. I wouldn’t repeat that experiment the same way, especially without a proper diagnosis of what had failed in the first place.
Unfortunately, the replacement X-clamp hardware caused another problem. The screw heads stuck out too far underneath the board, so the motherboard wouldn’t sit flat inside the metal chassis. There simply wasn’t enough clearance for the screws I’d chosen.
I also had to deal with the original heatsink mounting fittings before the new hardware could be installed. There were nylon and steel washers involved, and plenty of opportunities to discover another reason the arrangement wasn’t going to fit. Wonderful!
So after all that dismantling, cleaning, heating and fiddling with the clamps, the Xbox 360 still didn’t work. The repair was a complete failure, and I wasn’t particularly enthusiastic about spending any more time trying to rescue it.
I didn’t record a secondary error code to narrow down the actual fault, so I can’t tell you which component caused the original red-ring problem. What I can say is that my heat-gun and screw-and-washer adventure didn’t fix it, and the motherboard flexing certainly wasn’t a good sign.
As a rule, I upload my failures as well as my successes. There’s not much point pretending every repair works first time, and perhaps somebody watching this will avoid a few of the mistakes I made. Please learn from them. I insist!
At least I got some interesting high-speed footage out of the whole disaster, along with a pair of X-clamps that look rather like ninja stars. For now, I think I’ll go back to repairing something from the 16-bit era! :)
Sources
Related Posts